Pioneer Cemeteries and Their Stories,

Madison County, Indiana

McAllister Cemetery

Home Up

aka  Walker/McCallister

Adams Township

Location: west side of SR 109, between SR 36 and SR 38, south of Lick Creek

               Rows of Stalks and Stones

On the west side of SR 109, between SR 36 and SR 38, is the McAllister Cemetery.  It lies several hundred yards back a lane on a hill on the west side of a farmer's field.  This early settlers' cemetery cannot be seen in dense foliage from the highway.  The picture above is taken from SR 109 looking west during the winter; the picture below is taken from the cemetery looking east during the spring.

   

      The McAllister holds several pioneer families important to the development of southern Madison County.  John Markle, who was born in 1793 in New York, came to the area in 1823 and laid out the village of Markleville in 1854.  According to county historian Samuel Harden who knew him personally, John was "strictly honest; his word was as good as his note; ... a man of strong mind and will, though he had little education.  He was a great reader, and had the Constitution of the United States by heart."  John Markle died in 1865. (For more on Markle and Markleville, go to Adams Township page.)

  

William McAllister, whose family gave its name to this cemetery, is also of special note since he had a commission in the War of 1812.  He was born in 1788/92 in Kentucky but was moved to Virginia with his parents where he grew up and eventually married Bellana Frazier, 1796-1841.  In that state, he held offices in the county government.  He and family members moved to Madison County in the fall of 1835.  William and his family settled in Adams Township, and he lived on the same farm for twenty-nine years.  He died in February 1864.

    Relatives Thomas,1794-1852, and Garrett,1813-1864, McAllister and their families also came from Virginia and settled on the south bank of Lick Creek in the spring of 1828/9, earlier than William, according to family genealogists.  In years to come, other family members followed including several McAllister females who arrived in the area, married, and established homes. (For more on Garrett McAllister and Susan McAllister Brown, go to the Hardy-Culp page.)  The large McAllister family helped civilize and populate the untouched timber of Adams Township in those early pioneer days.  Along with other family members, all three McAllister men, mentioned above, are listed among the burials in this cemetery.   

 

The McAllisters/McCallisters family had prominent members in the broader community of Madison County.  Thomas McCallister was elected in 1842 as a representative to the Indiana State Legislature; he served for eleven years.  He was then voted to the state senate just before his death.  Others of the family held positions as sheriff, judge, and county commissioner.

   

    Among the other early Adams Township settlers buried at the McAllister is John Davis, 1800-1886, whom Samuel Harden, in his book The Pioneer, refers to as "one of the grand old men, whose memory we all revere."

    One of the earliest burials at the McAllister had to have been Meshach Collier.  Meshach was born in 1778 and died in 1833, according to his stone which is pictured at left.  Meshach and wife Rebecca, also listed below, were the parents of Rev. J.F. Collier who began the Union Baptist Church and accompanying cemetery southeast of this location. (See the Collier Cemetery page for more on the church, family, and cemetery.)

    Early 20th century Madison County historian Glen Walker was the first to make gravestone transcriptions of several of the pioneer cemeteries in the southern townships.  The McAllister was one of those he recorded, an arduous task considering the number of stones and the conditions of some of the graveyards at that time. Mr. Walker compiled the original list of gravestone data for the McAllister Cemetery in 1932 and revised it in 1962.   Mr. Walker turned over his records to the newly formed Cemetery Committee of the Madison County Historical Society in 1967.  Glen Walker's efforts remain invaluable.

    The McAllister pioneer cemetery is still in use.

Names
ID Names Birth Date Death Date Cemetery
4260 BENNETT, OSCAR V. 1906 1962 MCALLISTER
4363 BERK, (MARKLE) HANNAH 1831 1906 MCALLISTER
4983 BLAKE, FRANCES 70Y. 5M. 20D. AUG. 28, 1883 MCALLISTER
4984 BLAKE, FRANCIS C. 1860 NOV. 23, 1864 MCALLISTER
4988 BLAKE, GEORGE W. 2Y. 6M. 26D. MAR. 18, 1858 MCALLISTER
4996 BLAKE, JOHN 85Y. 20D. MAY 24, 1892 MCALLISTER
5029 BLAKE, SALUDA JANE 25Y. 5M. 17D. APR. 2, 1858 MCALLISTER
5054 BLANER, FRANCIS 70Y. 8M. AUG. 28, 1883 MCALLISTER
5055 BLANER, JOHN 85Y. 20D. MAY 24, 1892 MCALLISTER
5056 BLANER, SALUDA J. 25Y. 5M. 17D. APR. 3, 1858 MCALLISTER
8895 CAMPBELL, (MRS. J. P.) 1847 1930 MCALLISTER
8951 CAMPBELL, J. P. 1846 1891 MCALLISTER
8952 CAMPBELL, JACOB GODFREY 1854 1904 MCALLISTER
9325 CARPENTER, EMORY LEE 1880 1906 MCALLISTER
9374 CARPENTER, NORA 72Y. 3M. OCT. 26, 1932 MCALLISTER
9389 CARPENTER, TAYLOR 77Y. 5M. FEB. 5, 1936 MCALLISTER
11446 COCHRAN, NATHANIEL 1822 JAN. 29, 1853 MCALLISTER
11702 COLLIER, (MARKLE) MURL 1889 1919 MCALLISTER
11742 COLLIER, MESHACK 1778 OCT. 2, 1836 MCALLISTER
11751 COLLIER, REBECCA 75Y. 11M. 21D. FEB. 22, 1860 MCALLISTER
12219 COOK, ESTHER 19Y. 9M. 24D. JAN. 18, 1849 MCALLISTER
12256 COOK, LOUISA 2Y. 9M. 16D. AUG. 23, 1866 MCALLISTER
13466 CREASON, CHALMERS 1893 1955 MCALLISTER
13469 CREASON, FLORENCE 1898   MCALLISTER
13475 CREASON, MARY 28Y. 6M. 13D. JAN. 20, 1873 or 75 MCALLISTER
14672 DAVIS, (INFANT DAU.) 4M. 9D. APR. 23, 1898 MCALLISTER
14707 DAVIS, ANNA L. 63Y.   MCALLISTER
14727 DAVIS, BRITTANIE AUG. 7, 1831 SEP. 11, 1911 MCALLISTER
14757 DAVIS, CLARINDA 1836 APR. 9, 1875 MCALLISTER
14900 DAVIS, J. BENTON 7Y. 9M. 24D. JAN. 13, 1878 MCALLISTER
14918 DAVIS, JAMES H. 1837 APR. 19, 1906 MCALLISTER
14943 DAVIS, JOHN 86Y. 1M. 17D. MAY 30, 1886 MCALLISTER
14974 DAVIS, JOSIAH 1841 SEP. 15, 1952 MCALLISTER
15040 DAVIS, MARY 41Y. 4M. 16D. JUN. 27, 1849 MCALLISTER
15049 DAVIS, MARY CREASON   FEB. 11, 1884 MCALLISTER
15053 DAVIS, MARY JACKSON   JUN. 27, 1847 MCALLISTER
15154 DAVIS, SOLON C. 1870 1945 MCALLISTER
15158 DAVIS, SUSANNA 1848 JUN. 2, 1914 MCALLISTER
17528 EARLEY, BENJAMIN CARL 1Y. 9M. 19D. DEC. 13, 1903 MCALLISTER
17532 EARLEY, GLEN EDWARD 1911 1912 MCALLISTER
18584 ESTELL, IDA CHART 29Y. 7M. 9D. SEP. 15, 1896 MCALLISTER
18887 EVANS, JAMES 1825 1904 MCALLISTER
18892 EVANS, JOHN 76Y. 1M. 4D. FEB. 23, 1898 MCALLISTER
18916 EVANS, ROBERT CARSON JUL. 7, 1811 DEC. 12, 1883 MCALLISTER
19240 FATTIC, JOHN   1881 MCALLISTER
20600 FORD, ISAAC M. FEB. 8, 1829 APR. 18, 1886 MCALLISTER
20610 FORD, MARIAH NOV. 24, 1835   MCALLISTER
20733 FORT, BARTHOLOMEW     MCALLISTER
20739 FORT, MARGARET 63Y. 3M. 16D. AUG. 25, 1894 MCALLISTER
22701 GILES, MABEL 2M. 15D. JUN. 21, 1896 MCALLISTER
23142 GOE, WINAFRED 1845 DEC. 11, 1865 MCALLISTER
23525 GORDON, MARY 76Y. 3M. 10D. MAR. 22, 1895 MCALLISTER
24579 GUENTHER, LAURA 1890 DEC. 28, 1924 MCALLISTER
25978 HARDY, MAGGIE F. 22Y. 7M. 10D. JUN. 22, 1886 MCALLISTER
26783 HARTZELL, ELIAS 78Y. 5M. 19D. JUN. 21, 1934 MCALLISTER
26810 HARTZELL, SARAH ELIZABETH 85Y. 3M. 29D. OCT. 17, 1934 MCALLISTER
28476 HILBURT, ANNIE M. AUG. 5, 1873 NOV. 29, 1891 MCALLISTER
28477 HILBURT, JOHN FEB. 13, 1847 JUL. 24, 1902 MCALLISTER
28478 HILBURT, LOUISA F. 1854 JAN. 27, 1914 MCALLISTER
29071 HODSON, ANNA BELLE 1835 OCT. 25, 1896 MCALLISTER
29105 HODSON, JOHN DUDLEY 1836 1905 MCALLISTER
30262 HUDSON, (MARKLE) LOUESSA 1872 DEC. 6, 1893 MCALLISTER
31399 HUTSON, LORENZO DOW 1857 AUG. 20, 1913 MCALLISTER
32185 JARRETT, ANN S. 27Y. 7M. MAY 14, 1864 MCALLISTER
33006 JONES, ANN 75Y. 10M. 6D. JAN. 7, 1877 MCALLISTER
33136 JONES, EMMA 1863 1937 MCALLISTER
33168 JONES, GARRETT 1829 1838 MCALLISTER
33261 JONES, JOHN   APR. 7, 1858 MCALLISTER
33263 JONES, JOHN 63Y. 11M. 18D. APR. 10, 1886 MCALLISTER
33415 JONES, MORRIS HUDSON 1831 OCT. 12, 1861 MCALLISTER
33440 JONES, PAUL C. 38Y. 1M. 4D. APR. 25, 1882 MCALLISTER
33505 JONES, SARAH E. 1855   MCALLISTER
33507 JONES, SARAH E. 52Y. 11M. 10D. MAR. 8, 1901 MCALLISTER
33554 JONES, VIRGINIA 1825 MAY 4, 1837 MCALLISTER
33793 JUSTICE, ARCHIBALD 85Y. 3M. 28D. JUN. 7, 1894 MCALLISTER
33797 JUSTICE, EMILY 81Y. 6M. 26D. DEC. 25, 1891 MCALLISTER
33800 JUSTICE, ETHAN A. 1859 1923 MCALLISTER
33805 JUSTICE, IDA MAY 1869 1940 MCALLISTER
33807 JUSTICE, JOHN J. 1827 1895 MCALLISTER
33811 JUSTICE, LUCIAN 1871 1873 MCALLISTER
33812 JUSTICE, LUSTASIA 1831 1919 MCALLISTER
33815 JUSTICE, MARION T. 1839 1917 MCALLISTER
33816 JUSTICE, MARY CATHERINE 1838   MCALLISTER
33817 JUSTICE, MOLLIE 28Y. 8M. 14D. DEC. 25, 1889 MCALLISTER
34458 KEMERLY, ENOS 1833 1905 MCALLISTER
34461 KEMERLY, MARY J. 1838 1901 MCALLISTER
34469 KEMMERLY, ENOS or ENES 1833 1905 MCALLISTER
34470 KEMMERLY, MARY 1838 1901 MCALLISTER
37819 LEWIS, EDWARD LEE 1872 1903 or 1905 MCALLISTER
37825 LEWIS, ELIZABETH H. 34Y. 1M. 14D. MAR. 4, 1881 MCALLISTER
37879 LEWIS, JOHN T. 1841 1901 MCALLISTER
37908 LEWIS, MAGGIE L. 13Y. 6M. 11D. FEB. 17, 1882 MCALLISTER
37912 LEWIS, MARGARET   FEB. 17, 1862 MCALLISTER
37938 LEWIS, NANCY N. 1Y. 3M. 7D. JUN. 1, 1882 MCALLISTER
39715 MARKLE, ABNER A. 1843 1910 MCALLISTER
39716 MARKLE, ADAM 70Y. 3M. 19D. FEB. 19, 1862 MCALLISTER
39719 MARKLE, ANDREW JACKSON 23Y. 4M. 24D. JUL. 31, 1890 MCALLISTER
39720 MARKLE, ANN 1838 1918 MCALLISTER
39730 MARKLE, ELIZABETH J. 1863 1919 MCALLISTER
39731 MARKLE, EMERY ORAN 1890 1942 MCALLISTER
39734 MARKLE, EVA JANE 1868 1928 MCALLISTER
39739 MARKLE, HANNAH 75Y, 1906 MCALLISTER
39744 MARKLE, ISAAC C. 11M. 24D. JUL. 21, 1865 MCALLISTER
39745 MARKLE, JACOB 1802 1864 MCALLISTER
39747 MARKLE, JANE 1848 MAY 5, 1922 MCALLISTER
39749 MARKLE, JOHN   DEC. 18, 1866 MCALLISTER
39750 MARKLE, JOHN 72Y. 2D. DEC. 21, 1865 MCALLISTER
39753 MARKLE, JOHN E. 4M. MAR. 28, 1862 MCALLISTER
39754 MARKLE, JOHN F. 28Y. 11D. MAR. 10, 1896 MCALLISTER
39756 MARKLE, JOHN WARD 1904 1917 MCALLISTER
39759 MARKLE, LORAN 48Y. 6M. 22D. APR. 5, 1836 MCALLISTER
39760 MARKLE, LORENZO 11M. 13D. FEB. 18, 1870 MCALLISTER
39762 MARKLE, LOUESSA DEC. 30, 1872 DEC. 6, 1893 MCALLISTER
39765 MARKLE, MARY 67Y. 11M. 22D.